Planckety-Planck

With the launch of Planck and Herschel only two days away, excitement is reaching fever pitch. As the countdown inches slowly towards the moment of reckoning the tension mounts…

This post would have been a bit more exciting if all that had been true. Of course we now do have a definite launch window for Planck, 14th May 2009. The launch window opens at 14.12 BST and will remain open for about two hours. Let’s hope they manage to get the thing up in that time, otherwise there’ll be yet another substantial delay.

Planck will be launched with its sister-mission, Herschel.  They will both be carried by an Ariane 5 rocket from the European Space Agency’s launch site in Kourou, French Guyana. Within half an hour of launch, Planck and Herschel will separate and start on their journeys.  While both satellites are going to orbit the second Lagrangian Point (L2), they will have slightly different orbits.  It will take Planck around 6 weeks to get to L2, during which time it will start to cool down its cryogenic systems. Eventually it will be the coolest thing in space.

Of course that is all very exciting, but it would have been a lie to say that the excitement is mounting that much back here at home. Together with the fact that the undergraduate examination period is upon us, the department is extremely quiet and those that are most nervous have taken their jitters to South America. The fact is that most of the people directly involved with Planck or Herschel have actually been invited to the launch and have either already made their way there or have at least set out on their journeys to the jolly.

We do, however, plan to have a small function here to mark the  launch on Thursday with wine and nibbles and talks about the science. I hope it’s not tempting fate. I”m not exactly nervous myself, but probably will get butterflies as we watch the launch on the net. Still, there’ll be wine to steady our nerves…

I  remember very well the “launch”, in 1996, of a mission called Cluster which many of my colleagues at Queen Mary were heavily involved. This was the first flight of Ariane-5. Bugs in the software meant it lost control shortly after launch and the party very soon turned into a wake, although the resulting fireworks were quite spectacular.

Because the Ariane-5 vehicle was brand new, and somewhat untested, the European Space Agency had decided to take advantage of an offer to launch the mission without charge. This seemed like a good deal because the costs of putting an experiment in space are a sizeable fraction of the overall budget for such missions. It turned out, though, that the old expression was true. There’s no such thing as a free launch.

In fact, Cluster did eventually fly using flight spares and a launch on a Russian spacecraft. If Planck and Herschel go boom then there’s no way they can be replaced. It would be a terrible thing if this happened, for a large number of reasons, but Ariane-5 has launched many times since then, and I’m confident that both Planck and Herschel will soon be safely on their way to L2.

But don’t expect any science immediately, especially not from Planck. It will be years before the key science results emerge and, until then, the science team is sworn to secrecy….

11 Responses to “Planckety-Planck”

  1. telescoper's avatar
    telescoper Says:

    The reason Planck and Herschel are sharing the launch is because of the cost. The cost of an Ariane-5 launch runs into hundreds of millions of euros at commercial rates, a significant fraction of the cost of the whole mission.

    Scientific missions like this are not insured. It would be too expensive, even if an underwriter could be found.

  2. telescoper's avatar
    telescoper Says:

    I’m not an expert but I think these missions are not insured because the premiums are far too high to contemplate, probably because there are very few companies willing to underwrite them. I’d be interested to hear from anyone who knows more about it.

  3. Anton Garrett's avatar
    Anton Garrett Says:

    I’m sure the cost of insurance is why not. The premium, based on rocket reliability, would be a significant proportion of the cost of making the instrument, and it would have to get past the sponsors each time.

    Let’s hope that (1) they make it into orbit safely, and (2) on the way they don’t bump into the Shuttle that is currently repairing and upgrading the Hubble space telescope. This is an important week for astronomy.

    Where is the live internet feed of the launch?

    Anton

  4. telescoper's avatar
    telescoper Says:

    You’re assuming that there are underwriters willing to take on the risk for a premium that’s less than prohibitive.

  5. Anton Garrett's avatar
    Anton Garrett Says:

    Philip: I’m sure that insurance companies (if nobody else) have done detailed mathematical analyses of this sort. Such considerations were significant drivers of probability theory in the era after it was first quantified by Pascal and Fermat. I remember asking similar questions after an ordnance depot fire, when an MP asked if the government should have insurance against such events.
    Anton

  6. Hi Philip – what if all ten missions were funded by the same agency?

    We’re having a bit of a knees-up at Sussex too, hopefully linked up to the ESA live satellite feed, but apparently we get to pop open the champagne only “if all goes well”…

  7. […] my paper to the journal and the ArXiv before the little shindig we’ve been planning for the Planck launch gets under way at 1pm. Business as usual so […]

  8. Anton Garrett's avatar
    Anton Garrett Says:

    You can always use bookmakers as insurance agents…
    Anton

  9. Pippa Goldschmidt's avatar
    Pippa Goldschmidt Says:

    hi Peter
    Anything that is launched into outer space, and which the UK is involved with, should be insured – but this is a legal requirement to cover the health and safety aspects of the relevant risks (eg in case a bit of satellite falls onto someone’s head and they sue the UK Govt). Under UN treaties, the UK has liability for any damage caused in this way. See http://www.bnsc.gov.uk/5974.aspx for fascinating info about the The Outer Space Act.
    How do I know this? When I left Imperial I joined the civil service and became responsible for this regulation …

Leave a comment