From symbiont to parasite: the evolution of for-profit science publishing

Posted in Uncategorized with tags , , , , , , on November 19, 2026 by telescoper

I recently came across an article on PubMed Central called From symbiont to parasite: the evolution of for-profit science publishing, written by Peter Walter and Dyche Mullins of the University of Carlifornia at Santa Cruz. The abstract reads:

Two 17th century institutions—learned societies and scientific journals—transformed science in ways that still dominate our professional lives today. Learned societies like the American Society for Cell Biology remain relevant because they provide forums for sharing results, discussing the practice of science, and projecting our voices to the public and the policy makers. Scientific journals still disseminate our work, but in the Internet-connected world of the 21st century, this is no longer their critical function. Journals remain relevant almost entirely because they provide a playing field for scientific and professional competition: to claim credit for a discovery, we publish it in a peer-reviewed journal; to get a job in academia or money to run a lab, we present these published papers to universities and funding agencies. Publishing is so embedded in the practice of science that whoever controls the journals controls access to the entire profession. We must reform our methods for evaluating the contributions of younger scientists and deflate the power of a small number of “elite” journals. More generally, given the recent failure of research institutions around the world to strike satisfactory deals with publishing giant Elsevier, the time has come to examine the motives and methods of those to whom we have entrusted the keys to the kingdom of science.

This isn’t a new article – it was published in 2019 – and it says many things I have said already about the academic publishing racket – but I thought I’d share it here primarily because of the following picture:

The text accompanying it reads:

Non Solus (Latin for “not alone”) reads the banner of a woodprint adopted as a logo in 1620 by the House of Elsevier, a family of Dutch booksellers. The print shows a sturdy elm tree that supports a growing vine, which wraps around the trunk and entangles the branches (Figure 1A). The vine bears fruit, which a solemn scholar harvests with ease. In 1880, an unrelated publishing company adopted the venerable Elsevier name and logo, which according to its website: “…represents, in classical symbolism, the symbiotic relationship between publisher and scholar. The addition of the Non Solus inscription reinforces the message that publishers, like the elm tree, are needed to provide sturdy support for scholars, just as surely as scholars, the vine, are needed to produce fruit. Publishers and scholars cannot do it alone….”

Today, this 400-year-old logo no longer reflects reality. As scholars, we now could take over the means of fruit production–in fact, we already do most of it. Like our intellectual ancestors hundreds of years ago, we still conceive and execute the research, and we write the manuscripts. But now, with the advent of electronic word and image processing, we also create our own graphics, proofread our own text, and in some cases typeset it. More significantly, the Internet enables us to instantly disseminate our work around the world. Publishers provide a measure of quality control by orchestrating the peer review process, but here again it is scholars who do the actual work of reviewing papers. It is thus surprising that despite the diminished (and arguably dispensable) role of the publishing industry, our community remains slavishly committed to centuries-old traditions that, we will argue, are illogical and in many cases exploitative and harmful to our community.

(The emphasis is mine.) I agree with these comments. I just wish more people would actually start taking over the means of production – as we’ve been doing at the Open Journal of Astrophysics – rather than just talking about it.

LGBTQIA+ STEM Day!

Posted in LGBTQ+, Maynooth with tags , , , , on November 18, 2026 by telescoper

Just a quick post to point out that yesterday was LGBTQIA+ STEM Day, which aims to celebrate  to celebrate the work of LGBTQIA+ people in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM), but also to highlight the barriers still facing us. I actually drafted this yesterday, but forgot to post it!

For more information see here.

This also provides an opportunity for me to send my best wishes to all LGBTQIA+ staff and students at Maynooth and around the world! As far as I know, the institution in which I work is not marking this occasion.

P.S. I’m reminded that it was 23 years ago yesterday that Section 28 was finally repealed in England and Wales. With reactionary forces around the world attacking our hard-won rights, it is important not that we fight to hold on to what we’ve got.

Sixth Covid Booster

Posted in Biographical, Covid-19 with tags , , on November 17, 2026 by telescoper

Just for the record, today I had my 6th Covid-19 vaccination booster. As an Old, I get prompted by the HSE to get free Covid-19 boosters and winter ‘flu jabs so I booked an appointment at a local pharmacist as I did last year. It it took a bit longer this time round to get it done, as the place I used last year wasn’t offering any appoointments, so it’s been over a year since my last booster. Today I had three hours of lectures and left work a little earlier than usual, at around 4.30pm, to get my injection. I didn’t have to wait long and the vaccination itself only took a matter of minutes. They asked me to stay for around 10 minutes afterwards, in case.

That makes eight Covid-19 jabs altogether for me: the initial vaccination was in two stages, and I have since had six boosters. All but one of these have been Pfizer; the other one was Moderna (which I think was because they were trying to use up stock before it passed its expiry date).

As on previous occasions of this type I am feeling a bit tired – but then I usually feel tired on Tuesdays because it’s a busy day for teaching – so I’ll have an early night.

In the last few weeks I’ve had a bowel screen test, two knee injections, an eye examination, and now a Covid-19 booster. I think that will do for a while!

Euclid DR-Foundation: The Movie

Posted in Film, The Universe and Stuff with tags , , on November 17, 2026 by telescoper

Here’s a nice video explaining Euclid’s first data release (DR1-Foundation), and especially the profusion of strong gravitational lens systems found therein. The video is presented by Chris Pattison (Is he the new James Bond? Ed.)

Farewell to ADS…

Posted in Open Access with tags , , , , on November 16, 2026 by telescoper

For some time now, user of the SAO/NASA Astrophysical Data System have been presented with the message on the left warning them that ADS – as it is known for short – is about to be replaced.

Well, today (16th November 2026) is the day we bid farewell to ADS, though when I looked just now it was still reachable at its old web address. The information contained in ADS is not being lost, of course, but subsumed within Science Explorer (SciX for short) to which users will be redirected. The only thing I object to about SciX is its name, which is to Muskian for my tastes. I have dabbled with SciX in the past and found it a bit slower than ADS, so I’ve deferred switching completely until I am forced to, which I assume will be later today when the USA wakes up.

The Astrophysics Data System came online in 1992. I don’t remember when I started using it, but it can’t have been long after that. For the uninitiated, it is/was a digital library portal for researchers in astronomy and physics, operated by the Smithsonian Astrophysical Observatory (SAO) under a NASA grant. The ADS maintains bibliographic databases containing more than 15.0 million records, covering publications in Astronomy and Astrophysics, Physics, and (of course) the arXiv e-prints. In addition to maintaining its bibliographic corpus, the ADS tracks citations and other information, which means that it is an important tool for evaluating publication impact in these fields. All that will continue in SciX, of course, but those of us of a certain age will feel some sadness at having to say goodbye to a thing that has served us so well for so long.

We astrophysicists have been fortunate to have such a resource, and I think one of the aims of SciX is to expand its functions to other areas of science. Many research fields are forced to rely on junk databases such as Scopus which is so incomplete and error-strewn that it shouldn’t be taken seriously by anyone.

ADS usually updates at the weekend, usually the next but one after we publish in the Open Journal of Astrophysics and I usually therefore check it to see if everything is OK. For old times’ sake I report that, as of today, OJAp has 708 papers on ADS with a total of 10,731 citations (last week’s papers have not arrived there yet).

Sonnet No. 105

Posted in Poetry with tags , on November 15, 2026 by telescoper
Let not my love be call’d idolatry,
Nor my beloved as an idol show,
Since all alike my songs and praises be
To one, of one, still such, and ever so.
Kind is my love to-day, to-morrow kind,
Still constant in a wondrous excellence;
Therefore my verse to constancy confined,
One thing expressing, leaves out difference.
‘Fair, kind, and true; is all my argument,
‘Fair, kind, and true’ varying to other words;
And in this change is my invention spent,
Three themes in one, which wondrous scope affords.
‘Fair, kind, and true,’ have often lived alone,
Which three till now never kept seat in one.

by William Shakespeare (1564-1616)

The eyes have it

Posted in Biographical, Maynooth, Mental Health with tags , , , , , , , on November 15, 2026 by telescoper

Another thing that happened last week is that I had my eyes examined, it being just over two years since my last test. I always approach this event with some trepidation as in my experience it often leads to a new prescription and the consequent need to fork out a considerable amount of dosh on new spectacles. I wear varifocals as I have both astigmatism (which primarily affects long-distance vision) and the usual problem at close range for people of my age.

I’ve had the former problem for many years, but when I reached my mid-40s my short-range vision began to deteriorate rather rapidly, hence the need for varifocals, which are rather expensive but do work pretty well for me. Over the following decade or so every eye examination led to a new prescription, new lenses and new frames and a consequent reduction in my bank balance. Since I’m now an established member of the Over-Sixties Club I just assumed there would be steady deterioration from now on. That seemed to be the case in 2020 when I got new spectacles after a test.

Happily that doesn’t seem to have happened. Last time I went to the optician, in 2024, my prescription had not changed from the previous time (2022). In fact it has been stable since 2020. This time the only very slight change is that my long-distance vision has improved very slightly. I’m told that, even with their glasses on, many people can’t read the bottom line on the the Snellen chart and/or the Jaeger chart for reading. Happily I can do both. I am officially 20/20 with my spectacles on, which is very nice, as well as saving me some money!

Before the eye test itself I had a retinal exam which involved taking pictures of the back of my eyse. This wasn’t carried out by the optometrist but by an assistant, but the resulting photographs were delivered magically onto the optometrist’s computer screen and shown to me. It turns out my eyes are reasonably healthy. The pictures did, however, point out something I’ve known about for a while, which is that there is some unevenness in the surface at the back of both eyes and some signs of swelling of or near the optic nerves. The optometrist showed me the scan and pointed out these abnormalities, but said that it wasn’t anything to worry about as she thought it was historical rather than progressive. She said that such things sometimes occur in who have in the past sufffered some form of trauma to the head (which can cause increased pressure inside and so damage the back of the eyes). I have indeed experienced such a thing, 40 years ago.

Although I’d known about this issue for a while the optometrist made a new suggestion – that I should try to eat plenty of green leafy vegetables (such as spinach and kale). That’s not a problem for me as I like them and they are very nutritious. These vegetables, among others, contain lutein and zeaxanthin which are thought to prevent age-related degeneration of the macula (the region in the centre of the retina).

The optometrist also suggested that I should avoid direct sunlight* whenever possible. Over the years a number of people have remarked that I often have the blinds closed in my office during the day and much prefer subdued lighting; people have remarked on this when I do Zoom/Teams calls. Avoiding bright light in such ways was suggested by an optician some years ago, who suspected I might have some form of retinal damage but couldn’t see anything definitive with the technology available then. It seems he was right.

*Avoiding direct sunlight is not difficult in my office at Maynooth:

Montgomery, Elgar, Sibelius and Grieg at the National Concert Hall

Posted in Music with tags , , , , , , on November 14, 2026 by telescoper

Yesterday evening I once again took the train into Dublin for a concert by National Symphony Orchestra Ireland at the National Concert Hall in Dublin. The guest conductor for this occasion was Anna Rakitina.

After an appetiser in the form of a short piece called Overture by American composer Jessie Montgomery (no, not the gay pornstar), the main item for the first half of the concert was the Cello Concerto in E Minor by Edward Elgar. This was completed in 1919 but didn’t really become a regular part of the concert repertoire until the 1960s, largely as a result of the landmark recording by Jacqueline du Pré. I’ve never really rated Elgar as a great composer but I do think that his cello concerto is a masterpiece. It certainly has a great emotional depth than any other work that I can think of, with the possible exception of the Dream of Gerontius. The melodic beauty of the first movement Adagio really pulls at the heartstrings, but thereafter charts a path through varied moods and soundscapes, ending rooted in its minor key when other works of this type often shift into a major tonality. Although it is, at times, agitated and edgy, the overall atmosphere is sombre and reflective.

Last night’s soloist was Daniel Müller-Schott who gave a very fine account of this much-loved work, and returned to the stage after a standing ovation to give us an encore in the form of the wonderful Gigue from the Cello Suite No. 3 in C Major by Johann Sebastian Bach. That reminded that I must listen to the Bach Cello Suites again, as it has been far too long.

After the wine break we returned for the Symphony No. 7 by Jean Sibelius. This is very short for a symphony – only about 20 minutes – and is in a single movement. It’s also in C Major which you might think is a rather “plain” key for Sibelius to have chosen, but the piece is highly original in construction and wonderful to listen to in live performance. I have various recordings of Sibelius Symponies 1-6, but don’t have any of this one. I’d be grateful for any recommendations.

To end the concert we had the Peer Gynt Suite No. 1 by Edvard Grieg. This comprises some of the incidental music that Grieg wrote for Henrik Ibsen‘s play Peer Gynt. There are four pieces in the Suite, all of them very well established in the popular classics genre. My favourite is perhaps the least known of the four: a poignant expression of grief, The Death of Åse depicts the death of Peer Gynt’s mother; I think its simplicity makes it all the more moving. The most famous part is probably Morning which evokes a Nordic pastoral sunrise, except the setting in the play is North Africa.

I have to say I found it a strange choice to end the concert with this suite. It’s not that I dislike it, just that I think I prefer to finish with a more substantial work. I suppose it was added in because the Sibelius symphony is so short – normally a symphony would fill the entire second half of such a concert. Nevertheless it did send me home wanting to listen to Duke Ellington’s version of Peer Gynt.

Incidentally, on the way to the NCH earlier in the evening, around 6.30pm, while I walked down the western side of Merrion Square, I noticed a Garda cordon. I didn’t think much about it as there had been restrictions in Dublin for a few days owing to various European summits and whatnot. It was only when I got home that I realised that an explosive device had been placed there and dealt with by the defence forces…

Weekly Update from the Open Journal of Astrophysics 14/11/2026

Posted in OJAp Papers, Open Access, The Universe and Stuff with tags , , , , , , , , , , , , on November 14, 2026 by telescoper

It’s time for another Saturday update of activity at the Open Journal of Astrophysics. Since the last update we have published a further five papers, bringing the number in Volume 9 (2026) to 264 and the total so far published by OJAp up to 712.

I continue to include the posts made on our Mastodon account (on Fediscience); these announcements also contain a clickable form of the DOI for each paper. Our Mastodon account has regular updates and other announcements from OJAp too, including posts from the OJAp blog.

The first paper this week was published on Tuesday 10th November in the folder Instrumentation and Methods for Astrophysics . The title is “Fast and accurate bandpass integration of complex SEDs with neural networks” and it is writtenby Leo Alessandro Bianchi (U. Oslo, Norway). The authors introduce pyfine, a neural-network tool for fast, accurate spectral bandpass integration, achieving substantial speedups with minimal memory use across two test cases.

The overlay for this one is here:

You can find the officially accepted version on arXiv here and the announcement on Fediverse here:

Open Journal of Astrophysics

New Publication at the Open Journal of Astrophysics: "Fast and accurate bandpass integration of complex SEDs with neural networks" by Leo Alessandro Bianchi (U. Oslo, Norway)

doi.org/10.33232/001c.173831

November 10, 2026, 12:41 pm 1 boosts 0 favorites

The second paper for this week, published on Wednesday 11th November in the folder Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics is “Calibration of CMB Polarisation Using Cross-Experiment Correlations” by Claire Rigouzzo & Eugene A. Lim (King’s College London, UK) and Susanna Azzoni & Yiqi Liu (Princeton U. USA). This paper describes a cross-correlation method that calibrates polarization angles between CMB experiments without suppressing parity-violating signals, potentially improving calibration precision for searches for cosmic birefringence.

The overlay looks like this:

The official version of the paper can be found on arXiv here and the Fediverse announcement here:

Open Journal of Astrophysics

New Publication at the Open Journal of Astrophysics: "Calibration of CMB Polarisation Using Cross-Experiment Correlations" by Claire Rigouzzo & Eugene A. Lim (King's College London, UK) and Susanna Azzoni & Yiqi Liu (Princeton U. USA)

doi.org/10.33232/001c.175198

November 11, 2026, 10:21 am 1 boosts 1 favorites

The third paper of the week, also published on Wednesday November 11th, but in the folder Astrophysics of Galaxies is “The Entangling of Supernova Feedback Impacts with Coarsening Simulation Resolution” by Eric Zhang (U.C. Riverside, USA) and 13 others from USA, China, Italy, Germany and Canada. High-resolution dwarf-galaxy simulations show that supernovae suppress star formation locally in dense regions but drive outflows from diffuse gas—processes that coarse-resolution models cannot reliably distinguish.

The overlay for this is here:

The accepted version of this one can be found on the arXiv here and the Mastodon announcement here:

Open Journal of Astrophysics

New Publication at the Open Journal of Astrophysics: "The Entangling of Supernova Feedback Impacts with Coarsening Simulation Resolution" by Eric Zhang (U.C. Riverside, USA) and 13 others from USA, China, Italy, Germany and Canada.

doi.org/10.33232/001c.175199

November 11, 2026, 10:45 am 1 boosts 1 favorites

Our fourth paper of the week is “Effect of ionizing photon escape fraction in faint galaxies on modeling reionization history of the universe” by Zewei Wu, Andrey Kravtsov and Harley Katz (U. Chicago, USA). This was published on Friday November 13th in the folder Astrophysics of Galaxies. It explains how modelling suggests faint galaxies can drive hydrogen reionization, but their contribution depends strongly on ionizing-photon escape assumptions; constant or star-formation-based escape models fit observations better than strongly luminosity-dependent escape.

The overlay is here:

The officially accepted version of this paper can be found on arXiv here and the Mastodon announcement is:

Open Journal of Astrophysics

New Publication at the Open Journal of Astrophysics: "Effect of ionizing photon escape fraction in faint galaxies on modeling reionization history of the universe" by Zewei Wu, Andrey Kravtsov and Harley Katz (U. Chicago, USA)

doi.org/10.33232/001c.175276

November 13, 2026, 8:10 am 2 boosts 2 favorites

And the fifth and final paper for the week is “The Synthetic Absorption Line Spectral Almanac (SALSA)” by Dylan Nelson (U. Heidelberg, Germany) and 12 others distributed around the world. This was also published on Friday November 13th in the folder Astrophysics of Galaxies. SALSA is a public, extensive library of synthetic absorption spectra from cosmological simulations, designed to support studies of gas around galaxies, survey planning, and comparisons between simulations and observations.

The overlay for this one is here:

The officially accepted version of this paper can be found on arXiv here and the Mastodon announcement is here:

Open Journal of Astrophysics

New Publication at the Open Journal of Astrophysics: "The Synthetic Absorption Line Spectral Almanac (SALSA)" by Dylan Nelson (U. Heidelberg, Germany) and 12 others distributed around the world.

doi.org/10.33232/001c.175274

November 13, 2026, 8:23 am 2 boosts 1 favorites

That concludes this week’s update. There was a holiday in the USA on Wednesday 11th November, which meant no arXiv announcement the following day. I’ll do another update next week by which time we should have caught up on the backlog.

A Touch of Frost

Posted in Biographical, Maynooth with tags , , on November 13, 2026 by telescoper

This morning  I awoke to the first hard frost of the winter. Temperatures plunged yesterday and it’s cold on campus, but rather pretty.

Such sharp changes in temperature often lead to my arthritis flaring up. Earlier this week, however, I took my six-monthly trip to Naas for my knee injections. The treatment has kicked in with no adverse reactions, I’m doing fine, and looking forward to going into Dublin this evening for a concert at the NCH.