Archive for anomalous magnetic moment

The magnetic moment of the muon revisited

Posted in The Universe and Stuff with tags , , , , on June 10, 2025 by telescoper

A couple of years ago I posted an item about a measurement of the anomalous magnetic moment of the muon, a quantity usually known as (g-2). At the time this appeared to be in conflict with the predictions of the standard model (SM)of particle physics but the general opinion among experts was that the problem was likely to lie with the calculations rather than the experiment.

Well, catching up on things I missed during examination marking season, I refer you to a substantial paper (188 pages long) that appeared on arXiv on 27th May 2025, with the abstract:

If this is too small to read I direct yourself to the salient point, namely that “there is no tension between the SM and experiment at the current level of precision”.

It seems the Standard Model survives to fight another day…

Anomalous Media Coverage

Posted in The Universe and Stuff with tags , , , on August 14, 2023 by telescoper

Via a characteristically garbled piece in the Grauniad, bizarrely entitled Scientists may be on brink of discovering fifth force of nature, I found out that there has been an announcement of a new measurement of the anomalous magnetic dipole moment – known to its friends as (g-2) – of the muon. This new measurement is consistent with one made a couple of years ago, but with a smaller range of uncertainty. It’s an impressive result from an experimental point of view.

There is a news item explaining the new result here, which says

Precision test of particle’s magnetism confirms earlier shocking findings — but theory might not need a rethink after all.

That’s pretty much the opposite of what the Guardian piece says.

There’s also a video produced by the Fermilab Muon g-2 team that explains what has changed from 2021 to now:

My own view is that these recent experimental measurements of g-2, which seem to be a bit higher than theorists expected, can be straightforwardly reconciled with the predictions of the standard model of particle physics by simply adopting a slightly lower value of 2 in the theoretical calculations.

P.S. The classical value is of course  g-2 ≈ 7.81 m s-2.

The Effect of Gravity on the Muon Magnetic Moment

Posted in The Universe and Stuff with tags , , , , , on February 3, 2018 by telescoper

Only time for a short post today, but I think this may turn out to be an important result. There’s a paper by Morishima et al. on the arXiv with the rather dry title Post-Newtonian effects of Dirac particle in curved spacetime – III : the muon g-2 in the Earth’s gravity, which suggests that the anomalous magnetic dipole moment of the muon.

Here is the abstract of the paper. You can click on it to make it bigger.

In a nutshell the anomaly is that according to basic relativistic quantum theory in the form of the Dirac equation, the muon (and any other charged spin-1/2 fermion) should have a magnetic dipole moment μ of magnitude (given in terms of its mass m and fundamental constants) by μ=geħ/4m with the g-factor g=2 for Dirac fermions. The anomaly is that this can be measured and it appears that g differs from zero by a small but significant amount, i.e. (g-2) is not zero. It has been widely suggested that this discrepancy suggests the existence of physics beyond the Standard Model of Partlce Physics. Well, gravity is not included in the Standard Model so I suppose this could still be right, but the it this calculation may well disappoint those who were hoping that (g-2) might provide evidence for, e.g., supersymmetry when it looks like it might be something rather more mundane, ie the Earth’s gravity!

UPDATE: It appears there is an error in the paper; see here. You may stand down.

UPDATE: Well, that was pretty fast. There’s now a paper on the arXiv by Matt Visser that gives a detailed refutation of the above claim. Here is the abstract:

In three very recent papers, (an initial paper by Morishima and Futamase, and two subsequent papers by Morishima, Futamase, and Shimizu), it has been argued that the observed experimental anomaly in the anomalous magnetic moment of the muon might be explained using general relativity. It is my melancholy duty to report that these articles are fundamentally flawed in that they fail to correctly implement the Einstein equivalence principle of general relativity. Insofar as one accepts the underlying logic behind these calculations (and so rejects general relativity) the claimed effect due to the Earth’s gravity will be swamped by the effect due to Sun (by a factor of fifteen), and by the effect due to the Galaxy (by a factor of two thousand). In contrast, insofar as one accepts general relativity, then the claimed effect will be suppressed by an extra factor of [(size of laboratory)/(radius of Earth)]^2. Either way, the claimed effect is not compatible with explaining the observed experimental anomaly in the anomalous magnetic moment of the muon.

That’s how science goes!